Exhaustividad, preclusión de alegaciones y cosa juzgada en relación a las cláusulas abusivas. A propósito de las recientes resoluciones de la Audiencia Provincial de Palencia

  1. José María Roca Martínez
Journal:
Actualidad civil
  1. O'Callaghan Muñoz, Xavier (dir.)

ISSN: 0213-7100

Year of publication: 2017

Issue: 7-8

Pages: 56-63

Type: Article

More publications in: Actualidad civil

Abstract

Throughout this work we analyze the interpretation that the Palencia Provincial Court makes regarding the possibility of requesting the nullity of a ground clause and then claim the reimbursement of the unduly paid amounts through a subsequent process. This matter affects procedural concepts such as the issue, comprehensiveness, the estoppels or the extent of the concept res judicata. The confusion that exists regarding this matter is shown by the change of criteria and the return to the previous one in only five months and the dissenting vote of most of the Magistrates, that is repeated in the subsequent judgements.